Is AI making briefing worse? (Yes, yes it is.)

AI is great at filling in the gaps on a briefing form and speeding up the whole process, but not so great at figuring out what to include (or even what’s true). This can mean bland, generic briefs, which increase your chances of bland, generic content.

Bland, generic content is nothing new. AI-briefing just makes it almost inevitable.

‍

We’ve noticed something over the last year or so. Some of briefs coming into our writing agency sounding a bit samey. And all signs point to AI.

Now, we’re not talking about the dreaded em-dash or that annoying thing where every sentence is a new line. More like, repeated phrasing, long explanations for super simple concepts, and 1000-word briefs for 500-word articles. 

This isn’t a scold – we totally get why your business would use AI. Briefing is one of those jobs that AI seems made for. It’s annoying and repetitive, and your customers never see the outcome. So what’s the harm, right? 

The problem: AI seems to be making briefs worse. It’s great at filling in the gaps on a briefing form and speeding up the whole process, but not so great at figuring out what to include (or even what’s true). This can mean bland, generic briefs, which increase your chances of bland, generic content. 

Why does AI make briefing worse?

AI-generated content briefs often contain too much information, inaccurate facts and generic recommendations. Without clear human direction, they can create more work for writers and lead to less effective content.

Download Guide

So why are so many marketing managers using AI for briefing?

We’re not in the room, but we’d hazard a guess that a lot of it comes down to time. Teams are stretched and busy, briefing falls to the bottom of the list, and you just want to get something to your writer so the content gets written. AI gets it done. If you’re writing regular content – like monthly blogs – this can help keep you on track. 

AI is also really good at searching through screeds of information. Humans, not so much. So it’s a great tool if you’re briefing meaty, research-heavy articles or blogs. Get AI to pull out important facts and figures, complete with links, and you’re fine, right? Riiiight? 

‍

The shortcut makes things longer – four problems with AI-generated content briefs

Of course, with any too-good-to-be-true tech, there’s a catch. Actually, with AI briefing, there are a few. 

TMI 

The hallmark of an AI brief: waaaaay too much information. We’re seeing briefs for 500 word blogs that include 1000+ words of background information and context. It’s a sign that AI can’t handle specificity very well – it’s good at summarising and rewording, but not so great at knowing what’s most important.   

When your writer gets a brief that goes on for pages, they have to wade through all that information – relevant or not – to figure out what to include. That’s before they even start writing. Even worse, they might focus on the wrong thing or miss crucial details. Then, if the content is wrong, you have to give feedback and explain what you wanted in the first place, and those time savings from the briefing stage start to disappear. 

Mistakes and made-up facts   

AI is an answer machine. It basically wants to give you a response at all costs – it’s less concerned about little things like truth and accuracy. It’ll invent entire websites, fabricate quotes, and cite studies that don’t exist. 

If you’re using AI for a brief, it’s easy to see how making stuff up would be an issue. You don’t want to give your writer inaccurate information about what you do – especially if they’re outside your business and won’t be able to spot errors. And you really don’t want those inaccuracies to slip through the cracks and end up in an ad or on your website. 

You don’t know your own brief 

When you write a brief (or anything, really) you get to know it pretty well. The process of writing cements it in your brain. When AI writes something for you, that process doesn’t happen. You might read over the writing, but it won’t necessarily stick in your brain the same way. 

This makes it harder to explain to your writer – what exactly do you want them to do, again? It can also make it harder to see whether a piece of content matches the brief. And when you’re not on the same page as your brief or your writer, it can all slide off course very quickly. That’s when you end up with five rounds of revisions and still feel unsatisfied with the outcome. 

Same old, same old 

AI’s worst sin, in our eyes, is its tendency toward blandness and sameyness. It makes sense – AI is designed to filter through huge datasets, find patterns, and generate the most likely or average result. This is why users can end up with very similar outcomes, despite using different prompts. Think about those posters with the paint stroke font that are popping up at all your local takeaway joints.  

Use AI for briefing, and you’re going down the same path. Instead of content ideas, web copy or ad concepts that reflect your brand values or personality, you end up sounding the same as everyone else. That means your content is more likely to get lost in a sea of similar AI-generated content. 

‍

Shout out to VW and V&A for taking the veritable piss.

‍

It’s not the AI, it’s you (sorry) 

When AI has too much say over briefing, it can be a frustrating experience for everyone involved – we want to get it right the first time, and you don’t want to deal with multiple rounds of revisions either. 

However, that doesn’t mean you can’t use it. As with anything AI, the key is keeping a human perspective in the mix. You come up with the core strategy and purpose of the piece, AI writes the draft. You find the research and background info, AI sifts through it. You set the parameters around what needs to be included and how much information to provide, AI does the bullet points. AI writes the brief, you check it over before you send it to your writer. It’s treating AI as a tool, not handing over the reins. 

How to write a better content brief with AI

We're not saying don't use AI, just, like, do it well. Check that your AI-gen brief:

  • Clearly explains the purpose of the content and its intended audience.
  • Identifies the key message and desired action.
  • Includes relevant facts, examples and verified sources.
  • Reflects your brand's perspective, not generic industry advice.
  • Leaves out unnecessary background information.

‍

Want to know more about briefing? Check out our article about briefing basics blog.  

‍

Helen Steemson

The lead copywriter and creative director at Words for Breakfast. She spends much of her time working with the copy writing team across a variety of projects.